Best car insurance list by Defaqto, Which and AutoExpress

NFU Mutual, SAGA and LV top the ratings in the Defaqto, Which and AutoExpress surveys, see the full list of best car insurance companies...

Insurer Defaqto Which AutoExpress Average(%) Score out of 5
NFU Mutual 100%
(5/5)
81% 86.56% 89 4.5
SAGA 100%
(5/5)
73% 90.92% 88 4.4
LV 100%
(5/5)
74% 87.57% 87 4.4
John Lewis 100%
(5/5)
75% 83.03% 86 4.3
Cooperative Insurance Service 100%
(5/5)
68% 86.47% 85 4.2
Aviva 100%
(5/5)
69% 84.62% 85 4.2
RIAS 100%
(5/5)
72% 81.52% 85 4.2
Marks and Spencer 100%
(5/5)
66% 85.49% 84 4.2
AA 100%
(5/5)
67% 82.05% 83 4.2
Direct Line 100%
(5/5)
63% 82.95% 82 4.1
Esure 100%
(5/5)
63% 82.27% 82 4.1
Hastings Direct 100%
(5/5)
64% 81.91% 82 4.1
Sheila's Wheels 100%
(5/5)
66% 79.75% 82 4.1
RAC 100%
(5/5)
66% 77.15% 81 4.0
AXA 100%
(5/5)
60% 80.71% 80 4.0
Swiftcover 100%
(5/5)
60% 80.07% 80 4.0
More Than 80%
(4/5)
65% 82.57% 77 3.8
Churchill 80%
(4/5)
65% 83.74% 76 3.8
Privilege 80%
(4/5)
63% 81.81% 75 3.7
LloydsTSB 60%
(3/5)
59% 83.96% 68 3.4
Admiral 60%
(3/5)
58% 82.08% 67 3.3
Post Office 60%
(3/5)
61% 80.94% 67 3.3